Arbor, SIMS and iSAMS compared on their own pages, ahead of the DfE's 2027 MIS framework
Arbor, SIMS and iSAMS all describe themselves as cloud systems with census, attendance and assessment tools, and none publishes a price. The DfE expects its MIS framework to launch on 1 September 2027, and academy trusts must use it once it is live, so check your current contract before you plan a switch.

England: the DfE MIS framework and its guidance on current contracts are written for academy trusts and local authority maintained schools in England.
If you are thinking about changing your school's management information system (MIS), start with the end date of your current contract, not with a demo. The Department for Education (DfE) says its MIS framework is expected to launch on 1 September 2027, that single and multi-academy trusts must use it once it is live, and that local authority maintained schools are expected to. Until then, the DfE's advice is to keep any extension or stop-gap contract short and to write its core principles, including those on data and migration, into any new contract. This guide sets three MIS products used in England side by side, using only what each vendor publishes on its own website as read on 22 November 2026, and then sets out what the DfE's buying pages say switching involves.
An MIS is the system that holds a school's pupil and staff records and runs registers, assessment, behaviour, communication with parents and the school census returns. Because so much else connects to it, a change of MIS is a contract decision and a data project as much as a software choice.
The three systems and how their vendors describe them
Arbor. Arbor's School MIS page describes a cloud MIS used "from primaries to secondaries to Special Schools, APs and PRUs". Its feature list includes attendance, assessments, census, behaviour, SEN, exams, admissions, payments, communications and a parent portal and app.
SIMS. SIMS is now sold by ParentPay Group. Its SIMS MIS for schools page describes SIMS Next Gen as a cloud-native MIS "purpose-built for primary and secondary schools", sold in packages named Optimise, Pay, Engage, Finance and Secure, with a "Request a quote" button rather than a price.
iSAMS. The iSAMS MIS page describes a cloud-based system that "supports multi-curriculum for 3-18 years", with a core set of modules and further modules a school can add. The case studies on that page are from UK independent schools, and its migration page says iSAMS can be used by independent or international schools.
Other systems are sold to schools in England. These three were chosen because each publishes enough on its own pages to fill most of the table below.
Side by side, from the vendors' pages
"Not stated" means the pages listed in this guide's sources do not say. It does not mean the product lacks it: ask the vendor.
| Arbor | SIMS (ParentPay Group) | iSAMS | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cloud or installed | Cloud, hosted in Amazon Web Services' London data centre | Cloud-native SIMS Next Gen; the Optimise package lists "Hosting and support (optional)" | Cloud-hosted; hosting managed by iSAMS |
| Who it says it serves | Primary, secondary, special schools, APs and PRUs | Primary and secondary schools | Ages 3 to 18; independent or international, single or multi-site |
| Attendance | Yes (digital registers) | Yes, in Optimise | Registration Manager, in the core system |
| Assessment | Yes (marksheets and analysis) | Assessment, performance, exams and interventions, in Optimise | Gradebooks and Tracking Manager, as additional modules |
| School census | Census listed as a feature | Census and statutory returns, in Optimise | Census Manager, in the core system |
| Finance | Arbor Finance, a separate product aimed at local authority maintained schools | Finance package | Fee Billing Manager as an additional module |
| Parent app | Parent Portal and App | Parent and student app, in Engage | iParent App, as an additional module |
| Pricing model | Not published; packages named Core, Comms and Perform | Request a quote; no prices published | Not published |
| Data location | "We store, process and manage all personal data and backups in the UK" | "All customer data is held in UK or EEA data centres" (ParentPay Group trust centre) | "Multiple geographic server locations"; region not stated |
The Arbor package names come from its Pay-for-One Promise page, which says the Core package includes attendance, behaviour, progress tracking, census and statutory reporting, a custom report builder, student and staff profiles, and email and SMS. Arbor's data location is from its data protection page, and Arbor Finance is described on its Arbor Finance page. The SIMS data location is from the ParentPay Group trust centre, which covers the group's customers as a whole. The iSAMS hosting details are on its secure hosting page, which also says servers are backed up every hour with copies stored onsite and offsite.
Matching the table to your school
Read the table against your own situation rather than for a winner.
A local authority maintained primary that wants its finance system from the same vendor can compare Arbor Finance, which Arbor aims at maintained schools, with the SIMS Finance package, whose list includes data exchange with a local authority.
A school or trust whose data protection officer wants personal data held in the UK has a direct statement from Arbor. SIMS says UK or EEA. iSAMS mentions multiple server locations, but the pages read for this guide do not give a region, so that is a question for the vendor.
An independent school, or a group with schools abroad, will find that the iSAMS pages are written for them, including multi-curriculum support for ages 3 to 18.
Look closely at which package a feature sits in. In the table, iSAMS lists its parent app and gradebooks as additional modules, and the SIMS page splits payments, parent engagement and finance into separate packages. The DfE's core principles, below, ask suppliers to set out exactly what is core and what is a bolt-on.
What the DfE MIS framework changes
The DfE's page About the Management Information Systems framework describes an open framework for buying an MIS, expected to launch on 1 September 2027. Through it, schools will be able to buy standard modules, optional modules and additional services such as training and support. The DfE says all suppliers on it are assessed against its requirements, including data security, service standards and core MIS functionality, and that schools will be able to compare suppliers and see costs.
Who has to use it depends on the type of school:
- single and multi-academy trusts must use it once it is live, and this covers all MIS contracts a trust holds;
- local authority maintained schools and groups of maintained schools are expected to use it;
- further education providers can use it, but cannot get DfE procurement support.
Before launch, the page asks schools and trusts to check when their current MIS contract ends, review notice periods and renewal arrangements, and consider when they may need to procure a new MIS. The DfE says further information will be published as the framework develops. For how DfE frameworks work in general, see buying school IT through a DfE-approved framework.
Checking the contract you already have
The DfE's page What to do with your current MIS contract is the practical starting point for anyone thinking of switching. It says the contract details may be spread across order forms, a master agreement, schedules, online terms and conditions, support agreements, data processing agreements and invoices, and that you can also ask your supplier. Your MIS may involve more than one supplier, for example separate agreements for support, modules or systems that connect to the MIS, and trusts sometimes have different arrangements in different schools.
From those documents, confirm:
- who your supplier or suppliers are;
- the contract end dates;
- the notice periods;
- the renewal terms, including any automatic renewal;
- any break or exit clauses.
The DfE's guidance on timing is written for academy trusts, and it recommends local authority funded schools follow the same approach. Plan to buy your next contract through the framework as soon as possible after it launches and once your current contract expires, and do not use an extension that unnecessarily delays the move. If your contract ends before or shortly after launch and there is not enough time to buy through the framework, a short extension or renewal may be needed: the DfE says it should be temporary and for 12 months or less, and that you should check the notice period, the cost of extending, and whether support, module or integration contracts also need extending. If no short extension is possible, you may need to buy a new MIS before the framework is available, for up to 3 years, using the DfE's core principles in the contract.
Terms the DfE wants in a new MIS contract
The DfE's Core Principles for school MIS procurement set out terms to include if you buy before the framework exists. Schools should ask every bidding supplier to accept them, to make sure their own terms reflect them, and to agree that the principles take precedence where the two conflict. Several bear directly on switching:
- the supplier must hold Cyber Essentials Plus and/or ISO 27001, or be working towards it with completion due by spring 2027 at the latest;
- pricing must show what is in the core provision, any optional or modular bolt-ons, and every third-party integration, including whether it is one-way, two-way or through an aggregator;
- the contract may renew automatically only once, for at most 12 months, and the supplier should write to the school at least 6 months before expiry;
- contracts must not be longer than 3 years, including that additional term, and where the school buys support directly from the supplier under a separate support contract, that contract must end at the same time as the MIS contract;
- clicking to accept online terms in a portal does not count as agreeing the contract;
- school data must be stored and processed in the UK or European Economic Area unless a transfer complies with data protection law and is supported by appropriate transfer mechanisms and safeguards, and the supplier must tell the school in advance, naming at least the country and the recipient, for the school's prior written consent;
- the school must be able to get its data at any time, including during an exit period, at no extra cost, and bulk transfers are free up to 3 times a contract year and during exit, by download or API, in a "migration-ready, machine-readable format";
- the supplier must co-operate with migration on entry and on exit, the contract must set a timeframe and responsibilities for each migration, and during any exit period (the time in which the supplier provides termination assistance) the supplier must keep providing the service and access to the data.
How the vendors describe moving across
Each vendor publishes its own account of the move, and none gives a timeline on the pages read. Arbor's Moving to Arbor page sets out five steps: a call and demo, work with an onboarding team after signing, data migration with guidance and time "to thoroughly check everything before your Arbor site goes live", training, and then a customer success team. The iSAMS migration page offers "full migration and secure data transfer" and says schools can migrate from any in-house or commercial system.
Arbor's Pay-for-One Promise is aimed at schools tied to a SIMS contract until 2027 or 2028: the page says the core Arbor licence is free until that contract ends, that the school must fully use Arbor and stop using SIMS, and that it must give SIMS notice. Set any such offer against the DfE's timing above, especially if you are an academy trust.
Moving an MIS moves pupils' personal data to a new processor. The core principles make the school the data controller and the supplier its processor. The ICO's page When do we need to do a DPIA? lists data about vulnerable people and data processed on a large scale among the signs of likely high risk, and recommends a data protection impact assessment (DPIA) if in any doubt.
Common questions
- When does the DfE MIS framework start?
- The DfE's Get help buying for schools service says the MIS framework is expected to launch on 1 September 2027. Academy trusts will have to use it once it is live, for all the MIS contracts they hold, and local authority maintained schools are expected to use it.
- Can an academy trust sign a new MIS contract before the framework launches?
- The DfE says a trust may need a short extension or renewal of 12 months or less if its contract ends before or shortly after launch, and that if no extension is possible it may need to buy a new MIS for up to 3 years, using the DfE's core principles in the contract.
- Do school MIS vendors publish their prices?
- Not on the pages read for this guide on 22 November 2026. SIMS asks schools to request a quote, and Arbor and iSAMS publish no pricing.
Sources
Every requirement, licence detail and figure in this guide comes from these pages, read on 22 November 2026. Guidance, licences and products change: check the source before you rely on one.
- About the Management Information Systems framework (Department for Education (Get help buying for schools))
- What to do with your current MIS contract (Department for Education (Get help buying for schools))
- Core Principles for school MIS procurement (Department for Education (Get help buying for schools))
- School MIS (Arbor)
- Data Protection and GDPR (Arbor)
- Arbor Finance (Arbor)
- Pay-for-One Promise (Arbor)
- Moving to Arbor (Arbor)
- SIMS MIS for schools (ParentPay Group)
- Trust centre (ParentPay Group)
- Cloud-based School Management Software (iSAMS)
- Migration (iSAMS)
- Secure Hosting (iSAMS)
- When do we need to do a DPIA? (Information Commissioner's Office)
Spotted something wrong or out of date? Tell us and we will correct it.
Keep reading
More education guides
All education guides
Running school ITBuying school IT through a DfE-approved framework, from finding one to awarding the contract
21 Nov 2026 7 minRead
Accounts, Microsoft 365 and GoogleMicrosoft is retiring its free school plan in 2028, and that changes the choice with Google Workspace
22 Nov 2026 8 min
Cyber security and RPASpotting a phishing email at school, and reporting it even after you have clicked
22 Nov 2026 8 min