Skip to main content

Security keys for a small team: when they are worth buying

For most staff, a passkey on the phone or laptop they already have gives the same protection against phishing as a hardware security key, on hardware they already have. Buy keys for the accounts that can do the most damage, such as administrators, and for people who can't use a phone at work. Give each key holder two keys, or a second sign-in method, before you switch anything off.

KBY Small Business 7 min read Sources checked 21 November 2026
A hand plugging a small black USB device into the side port of a black laptop
Photo: Aleksander Dumała on Pexels

Start with the passkeys your staff's phones and laptops can already hold, and buy hardware security keys only where they add something: for administrator accounts, for people who can't use a phone at work, and for shared computers. A security key and a passkey on a phone are built on the same standard, FIDO2, and the NCSC puts both at the top of its list of recommended MFA methods. The difference is where the credential lives and what happens when it is lost.

What a key does that a code or a prompt doesn't

The NCSC's April 2026 assessment of passkeys is blunt about older second steps. It says all traditional MFA methods, including SMS codes, email codes, codes from authenticator apps or physical tokens, and push approvals, are inherently phishable: a code or an approval can be watched and relayed by a fake sign-in page while the attack is live. It assesses FIDO2 credentials, including passkeys, as at least as secure as traditional MFA against every common credential attack it looked at.

The reason is in how they work. Microsoft's passkeys (FIDO2) overview explains that the private key stays on the device and the public key sits with the service, so a passkey only works for the website or app it was created for. The person also has to be present to unlock it with a fingerprint, face or PIN each time. A fake login page gets nothing it can reuse.

A hardware security key is one place to keep that credential. The FIDO Alliance describes a passkey as a credential that can be stored on your phone or computer, or in a hardware security key. Microsoft calls security keys device-bound passkeys on a physical authenticator, where the private key never leaves the key.

Use what staff already carry first

The built-in option comes first, because it needs no new hardware. The NCSC says passkeys are already supported by most modern devices, and its multi-factor authentication guidance puts FIDO2 credentials at the top of its list of recommended methods whether they are held on a trusted "platform" device, such as a laptop with Windows Hello for Business or Touch ID, or on a "roaming" security key. It does not rank one above the other.

Microsoft's guidance draws the line for you. It says that for most users, those outside highly regulated environments or without access to sensitive systems, synced passkeys (ones stored with a cloud passkey provider and usable on the person's other signed-in devices) offer a convenient, low-cost alternative to traditional MFA. It names passkeys in the Microsoft Authenticator app as another option, even for the people it would otherwise give a key.

Google's 2-Step Verification admin help makes the same point from the other side: its "Only security key" setting now accepts passkeys as well as security keys, and Google says the two have the same level of phishing protection.

So if your team signs in to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace with a password and an authenticator code or push prompt today, moving them to passkeys on their own devices is the bigger step up. A key is a choice you make for particular people on top of that.

Where a key is worth the money

Microsoft's overview recommends FIDO2 security keys for highly regulated industries and for users with elevated privileges. The NCSC's guidance gives the same example: every IT administrator issued with a hardware key that must be used for administrative interfaces. In a small firm that means whoever holds the Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace admin account.

The NCSC lists other situations where FIDO2 is likely to fit and a phone-based method is not:

  • the person often works where mobile phones are not allowed;
  • they work where mobile signal is unreliable or missing;
  • they use a shared workstation, and carry a key to sign in on whichever computer they are at that day.

The NCSC also says a phone-based challenge app is less likely to be appropriate when the user doesn't have a trusted device to respond to it. If some of your staff don't have a work phone and you would rather not rely on their personal one, a key gives them strong sign-in without it. The NCSC's January 2025 blog on passkeys made a related point: passkeys assume the person has private use of their own device, which isn't true for everyone.

A key also suits a service that accepts only device-bound passkeys. The NCSC noted that some websites support synced passkeys while others only support device-bound ones, and Microsoft's overview says that if attestation (checking the make and model of the authenticator) is switched on, only device-bound passkeys are allowed and synced ones are excluded.

Where it probably isn't

Keys cost money beyond the purchase. Microsoft says they can increase costs for equipment, training and helpdesk support, especially when users lose their keys and need their accounts recovered. The NCSC says FIDO2 is less likely to be appropriate when you can't buy, issue and manage a key for each person, or when the service doesn't support FIDO2 directly or through single sign-on.

A key also only protects the sign-ins that ask for it. The NCSC's page on MFA anti-patterns warns that older protocols, such as legacy email connections, can let someone in with only a password even when strong MFA is enforced everywhere else, and that accounts excluded from MFA because it's "too much of a nuisance" are often the ones with access to the most sensitive data. Buying keys doesn't close either gap. Switching off legacy sign-in and covering every account with access to sensitive data does.

Choosing a key

If you decide to buy, the questions are practical: which ports your laptops have, whether staff need to use the key with a phone, and whether you need anything beyond passkeys.

  • Connector. Match USB-C or USB-A to the computers people actually use. Yubico sells the YubiKey 5C NFC with USB-C and the YubiKey 5 NFC with USB-A.
  • NFC. A key with NFC can be tapped against a phone instead of plugged in. Yubico lists tap-and-go sign-in on NFC-enabled Android and iOS devices for these models.
  • FIDO only, or more. Yubico's Security Key C NFC supports only FIDO2/WebAuthn and FIDO U2F, which Yubico describes as its more affordable option. The YubiKey 5 series adds one-time passwords, smart card (PIV) and OpenPGP. If all you need is passkey sign-in to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, the FIDO-only key covers it.

Yubico lists up to 100 passkey slots on each of these keys and says they need no battery or network connection. Google's security key help says any FIDO1 or FIDO2 key can be used as a second step for 2-Step Verification, and that signing in with just the key, without a password, needs a key that supports FIDO2. Yubico prices its keys in US dollars on its own store, so check the current UK price where you buy.

Two keys, or a way back in

The most important rule with keys is that nobody should depend on only one. Microsoft's deployment guidance says it is always recommended that users have at least two authentication methods registered, so there is a backup if the main one is lost or stolen. Google's help suggests getting an extra key to keep in a safe place, and adding more ways to prove it's you in case a key is lost.

In practice, give each key holder either two registered keys, with the spare kept somewhere safe away from the first, or one key plus a passkey on their phone or laptop. Write down who has which key, so a lost one can be removed from the account.

Know your way back in before you need it. In Google Workspace, if you enforce the "Only security key" option, users cannot generate their own backup codes: an admin has to create one for them, and Google says to set a grace period during which a user can sign in with that code, which it describes as useful when a user loses their security key. In Microsoft Entra, once the Temporary Access Pass is turned on in the Authentication methods policy for the users it should cover (do this in advance), an admin can issue a Temporary Access Pass, a time-limited passcode that Microsoft says makes recovery easier when a user loses or forgets a strong authentication method. And keep at least two people able to do those recoveries, so the person who has lost their key is never the only one who can fix it.

Turning it on

Setup is done in your own admin console, and both vendors keep their own step-by-step pages: Microsoft's how to enable passkeys (FIDO2) in Microsoft Entra ID and Google's deploy 2-Step Verification. Follow theirs rather than a copy, because the screens change.

Whichever you use, try it on one account first. Microsoft's setup page lets you apply passkey settings to a target group, so start with a pilot group holding one test account, register two methods on it, sign out, sign back in with each, and only then add real people. Don't make a key the only accepted method for anyone until they have a working second one. For the wider picture of what MFA Cyber Essentials expects, see our Cyber Essentials guide.

Products that help with this

Partner links
  • Yubico · PaidSecurity Key C NFC by YubicoYubico's more affordable FIDO-only key, with USB-C and NFC, for staff who only need passkey sign-in.Check partner offer
  • Yubico · PaidYubiKey 5C NFCA USB-C and NFC key that adds one-time passwords, smart card (PIV) and OpenPGP to FIDO2, for admins whose systems need more than passkeys.Check partner offer
  • Yubico · PaidYubiKey 5 NFCThe USB-A version with NFC, for computers that don't have a USB-C port.Check partner offer

Partner links are sponsored: KBY may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. Whether a company pays KBY does not decide what we recommend, and nothing here is needed to follow the guide. Advertising disclosure.

Common questions

Does every member of staff need a security key?
No. Microsoft recommends security keys for regulated industries and users with elevated privileges, and says synced passkeys are a convenient, low-cost alternative for most other users. The NCSC ranks a passkey on a trusted laptop or phone alongside a roaming key at the top of its list of MFA methods.
Is a passkey on a phone as strong as a hardware key?
Against phishing, yes. Google says passkeys and security keys have the same level of phishing protection, and the NCSC assesses FIDO2 credentials, passkeys included, as at least as secure as traditional MFA. The difference is that a key keeps the credential on one physical device, which some services and settings, such as Microsoft's attestation option, require.
What happens if someone loses their only key?
They can't sign in with it, so plan for that before it happens: register a second key or a passkey on their phone or laptop, and know how an admin issues a way back in, such as a Google Workspace backup code or a Microsoft Temporary Access Pass. Then remove the lost key from their account.

Sources

Every requirement, price and figure in this guide comes from these pages, read on 21 November 2026. Schemes, prices and products change: check the source before you rely on one.

  1. Passkeys are more secure than traditional ways to log in (NCSC)
  2. Multi-factor authentication for your corporate online services: Recommended types of MFA, Version 2.0, reviewed 26 September 2024 (NCSC)
  3. Multi-factor authentication for your corporate online services: Avoiding MFA anti-patterns, Version 2.0, reviewed 26 September 2024 (NCSC)
  4. Passkeys: they're not perfect but they're getting better (NCSC)
  5. Passkeys (FIDO2) authentication method in Microsoft Entra ID (Microsoft)
  6. Get started with a phishing-resistant passwordless authentication deployment in Microsoft Entra ID (Microsoft)
  7. Configure a Temporary Access Pass in Microsoft Entra ID to register passwordless authentication methods (Microsoft)
  8. How to enable passkeys (FIDO2) in Microsoft Entra ID (Microsoft)
  9. Deploy 2-Step Verification (Google)
  10. Use a security key for 2-Step Verification (Google)
  11. FIDO Passkeys: Passwordless Authentication (FIDO Alliance)
  12. Security Key C NFC by Yubico (Yubico)
  13. YubiKey 5C NFC (Yubico)
  14. YubiKey 5 NFC (Yubico)

Spotted something wrong or out of date? Tell us and we will correct it.

Keep reading

More small business guides

All small business guides
Share this guideXLinkedInFacebookEmail
All small business guides

The KBY Brief

A short email about twice a week with new runbooks, configuration traps and fixes from KBY Technologies.