Skip to main content

Phishing in a small team: what to teach staff, and what to do when someone clicks

Teach staff the common signs of a scam message, but don't expect training to catch everything: the NCSC says no training package can teach people to spot every phishing email. Put more effort into a reporting route nobody is afraid to use, checks on payment and password requests, and a short list of what to do when someone has clicked.

KBY Small Business 7 min read Sources checked 22 November 2026 UK
Close-up of a blue Mail app icon on a smartphone screen
Photo: Brett Jordan on Pexels

UK: the reporting routes are for the UK, with different police contacts in Scotland.

Someone in your team will click a link in a scam email at some point, and the useful question is what happens next. The NCSC's guidance on defending an organisation against phishing says plainly that no training package, including phishing simulations, can teach users to spot every phishing attempt, and that some attacks will always get through. So train people to recognise the obvious ones, make reporting quick and blame-free, and decide in advance what you will do after a click.

Phishing, in the NCSC's words, is when attackers send scam emails or text messages containing links to malicious websites. The site might install malware such as ransomware, or trick the person into giving away a password or sending money. The NCSC's small organisations guide says 85% of cyber attacks against businesses start with a scam email, which is why this deserves an hour of your time even in a team of five. The NCSC's phishing guidance is written mainly for medium and large organisations; it suggests smaller ones also look at its Cyber Action Toolkit.

What staff can realistically learn to spot

The NCSC's small organisations guide lists the tell-tale signs it shows on an example phishing email:

  • misspelled email addresses;
  • unexpected attachments;
  • generic greetings like "Dear valued customer";
  • links that go to unknown sites;
  • spelling and grammar mistakes;
  • poor quality or strange-looking logos.

Two more points from the same page are worth repeating at a team meeting. Scam messages often pretend to come from someone you know or trust, such as a bank or a part of government, and push you to act fast. And when in doubt, contact the organisation directly using the details on its official website, never the phone number or link in the message.

That habit still works when the signs don't. An email sent from a real supplier's hacked account can look right in every way listed above, but a call to the number you already hold for that supplier reaches the real person.

Why the NCSC is wary of phishing tests

Many training products sell simulated phishing campaigns: fake scam emails sent to your own staff to see who clicks. The NCSC's guidance is cautious about them, for reasons that matter even more in a small team where everyone knows each other.

It says asking people to examine every email in depth would leave no time for work, because clicking links is part of the job. It warns that punishing people for clicking emails you sent yourself starts to resemble entrapment, and that you should check with HR before running a simulation. It also says simulations erode trust: staff who are afraid for their jobs will not report mistakes.

If you do measure anything, the NCSC suggests counting how many people reported a phishing email, not just how many clicked.

The guidance offers an alternative some organisations use instead of simulations: ask staff to write their own phishing email, which gives them a richer view of the tricks scammers use without anyone feeling tested.

Make reporting the easy, blame-free option

The NCSC calls staff who report quickly a valuable early warning system, and says users who fear reprisals will not report mistakes promptly, if at all. Its guidance asks for a reporting process that is clear, simple and quick to use, quick feedback on what was done about each report, and no punishment or blame culture around phishing, so that people come forward even after they have clicked.

For a small business that can be as simple as:

  1. One place to report. A named person, or a shared address everybody knows, for "I'm not sure about this email" and "I think I clicked something".
  2. A reply every time. Thank them and say what happened. The NCSC says feedback should show people their reports make a difference.
  3. A rule that reporting a click is never a disciplinary matter. Say it out loud and put it in writing: the NCSC's point is that people who fear blame report late, or not at all.

Staff should also report scam emails to the NCSC. Its Suspicious Email Reporting Service takes forwarded emails at report@phishing.gov.uk. The NCSC says to forward anything that feels suspicious even if you are not sure, not to click any links in it, and that there is no need to forward emails already sitting in your spam or junk folder. It analyses the email and the sites it links to, and may work with hosting companies to remove malicious sites. It does not tell you the outcome.

Change the processes scammers copy

The NCSC points out that attackers copy everyday ways of working to get people to hand over passwords or make payments. Its advice is to make those processes harder to fake, rather than relying on people's eyes alone. Its guidance suggests:

  • making sure staff know the normal way key tasks are done, such as how payments are made, so an unusual request stands out;
  • verifying every important email request through a second channel, such as a phone call, logging into the account directly, or confirmation in person;
  • sharing files through an access-controlled cloud account rather than as email attachments;
  • telling customers and suppliers what you will never do, such as "we will never ask for your password" or "our bank details will not change".

The NCSC says checks like these make processes more resistant to phishing, and the second one is the check to apply to payments. Agree as a team that a change of bank details, or an urgent request to pay, is always checked by phone on a number you already have, however senior the sender appears to be.

The NCSC also suggests reviewing what your website and social media give away. Staff profiles, details of suppliers and personal posts all help a scammer write a convincing message to the right person.

Limit the damage when a click gets through

Because some phishing will succeed, the NCSC's guidance puts as much weight on limiting the effect of a click as on preventing it. For a small business the steps that carry most of that weight are:

  • Multi-factor authentication (MFA) on email and other important accounts. Also called two-step verification, it means a stolen password alone is not enough to get in.
  • A password manager. The NCSC notes that some will not fill in a password on a fake website, which gives people another clue that something is wrong.
  • Separate admin accounts. Limit administrator accounts to the people who need them, and don't use them to read email or browse the web, so a click on an ordinary account is less likely to install malware.
  • Supported, updated devices and software, so malware can't use known weaknesses that already have a fix.
  • Removing accounts when people leave or change role, and reviewing who has privileged access.

The NCSC adds that most modern browsers block known phishing and malware sites, but that this is not always the case on mobile devices.

The first hour after someone clicks

Agree these steps now, while nothing is happening, and keep them somewhere staff can find them without their usual device. The NCSC's guidance points out that people may not be able to use their normal way of reporting if their device is compromised.

The NCSC's page for people who have shared information with a scammer gives the actions by situation. Applied to a work account, they become:

  1. Tell whoever looks after IT straight away. For a message received on a work laptop or phone, the NCSC says to contact your IT department.
  2. If a password was typed into the fake page, change it, and change it on any other account that uses the same password. Where the service supports a passkey, the NCSC suggests using one instead.
  3. If a link was opened or software installed, run a full scan with the device's antivirus and let it clean up what it finds.
  4. If bank details were given, contact the bank.
  5. If the account may already be in someone else's hands, for example messages you did not send or being locked out, follow the NCSC's advice on recovering a hacked account.
  6. If money was lost, tell the bank and report it as a crime to Report Fraud (England, Wales and Northern Ireland) at reportfraud.police.uk or on 0300 123 2040, or to Police Scotland on 101.

Then look at whether personal data was involved. If someone got into a mailbox full of customer details, you may have a personal data breach to assess. Our guide to reporting a personal data breach to the ICO explains when one must be reported and how.

A plan you have practised

The NCSC's small organisations guide compares this to fire safety: just as everyone knows what to do if there is a fire, the business should have a plan for a cyber attack that says who does what, and when. Its phishing guidance adds that a plan should be practised before an incident, and points to Exercise in a Box, its free online tool for rehearsing a response.

A one-page plan is enough to start: who to tell, how to reach them without email, who can reset passwords, who calls the bank, and who decides whether the ICO needs to know. Walk through it once with a made-up scam email and fix whatever was unclear.

Common questions

Should we run fake phishing emails to test our staff?
The NCSC is cautious about it. It says simulations can't teach people to spot every phishing email, that punishing people for clicking emails you sent starts to resemble entrapment, and that you should check with HR first. It suggests measuring how many people report suspicious emails, not only how many click.
Where do we send a suspicious email?
Internally, to whoever looks after IT. Externally, forward it to the NCSC at report@phishing.gov.uk. You don't need to forward emails that are already in your spam or junk folder.
Someone typed their password into a fake login page. What first?
Tell whoever looks after IT, change that password straight away, and change it on any other account that uses the same one. If there are signs someone else has been in the account, such as messages you didn't send, follow the NCSC's advice on recovering a hacked account.

Sources

Every requirement, price and figure in this guide comes from these pages, read on 22 November 2026. Schemes, prices and products change: check the source before you rely on one.

  1. Phishing attacks: defending your organisation (NCSC)
  2. Small organisations guide to cyber security: Spotting cyber attacks, Published 9 April 2026, reviewed 21 July 2026 (NCSC)
  3. Report a scam email (NCSC)
  4. Phishing scams: If you've shared sensitive information, Version 2.0, reviewed 5 September 2022 (NCSC)

Spotted something wrong or out of date? Tell us and we will correct it.

Keep reading

More small business guides

All small business guides
Share this guideXLinkedInFacebookEmail
All small business guides

The KBY Brief

A short email about twice a week with new runbooks, configuration traps and fixes from KBY Technologies.